Current:Home > MarketsARPA-E on Track to Boost U.S. Energy, Report Says. Trump Wants to Nix It. -Elite Financial Minds
ARPA-E on Track to Boost U.S. Energy, Report Says. Trump Wants to Nix It.
View
Date:2025-04-25 23:29:31
The government’s incubator for financially risky innovations that have the potential to transform the U.S. energy sector is on track and fulfilling its mission, according to a new, congressionally mandated review. The findings come on the heels of the Trump administration’s proposal to cut the program’s budget by 93 percent.
Congress created ARPA-E—Advanced Research Projects Agency-Energy—in 2007 to research new energy technologies and help usher them to market. It has funded advances in biofuels, advanced batteries and clean-car technology, among other areas.
The Trump administration argued in its budget proposal in March that the “private sector is better positioned to advance disruptive energy research and development and to commercialize innovative technologies.”
But Tuesday’s assessment by the National Academies of Science, Engineering and Medicine makes a different case, saying, in effect, that private industry can’t afford the same kind of risk or enable the same kind of culture that leads to ground-breaking developments.
The assessment concluded that ARPA-E is doing what it set out to do and is not in need of reform, as some critics have suggested. Its authors pointed out that the program is intended to fund projects that can take years or decades to come to fruition.
“It is too early to expect the revolution of the world and energy,” said Dan Mote, chairperson of the study committee and president of the National Academy of Engineering. “But the fact is it is alive and well and moving forward in the right direction.”
The program was modeled on DARPA (Defense Advanced Research Project Agency), the government research engine that developed the internet. Like DARPA, the project’s goal is to identify promising research that private industry can’t afford or won’t take on. But unlike DARPA, the program’s activities are carried out in public view. Under a mandate from Congress, ARPA-E has to be reviewed every six years.
Its progress is especially remarkable, the report’s authors say, given the budget constraints the program faces. ARPA-E costs about $300 million a year — a figure that industry leaders have said should be closer to $1 billion at least. (The program was created during the Bush administration as part of the America COMPETES Act, but wasn’t funded until 2009.) In a 2015 report, the American Energy Innovation Council, which counts Bill Gates among its leading executives, said that the government spends less on energy research than Americans spend on potato and tortilla chips.
Tuesday’s report found that ARPA-E’s unique structure—helmed by new program directors who rotate in every three years—was a key to its momentum. Its ability to take risks, the study committee argues, distinguishes it from other funding programs, including in the private sector.
“One of the strengths is its focus on funding high-risk, potentially transformative technologies and overlooked off-roadmap opportunities pursued by either private forms or other funding agencies including other programs and offices in the DOE (Department of Energy),” said Louis Schick, a study committee member and co-founder of New World Capital, a private equity firm that invests in clean technology.
The renewable energy industry, which has expressed concerns about Trump’s proposed cuts, said the report underscores ARPA-E’s role in developing breakthrough technologies.
“We don’t know yet whether ARPA-E will unlock a game-changing energy technology like it’s cousin DARPA famously did with the internet, but the report clearly outlines how ARPA-E is well-structured for success going forward,” said Scott Clausen, policy and research manager at the American Council on Renewable Energy. “There is no denying that this program fills a critical void in funding high-risk, high-reward research—an essential ingredient for our overall economic competitiveness.”
The review’s authors were careful to make clear that ARPA-E wasn’t pursuing overly risky projects on the taxpayer dime.
“It’s not a failure when you stop when you learn it can’t be done,” Schick said. “It’s a failure if you keep going.”
veryGood! (4)
Related
- Federal Spending Freeze Could Have Widespread Impact on Environment, Emergency Management
- Ukraine says Russia blew up major dam from inside, endangering thousands of people and a nuclear plant
- Ridiculousness Reveals Star-Studded Lineup of Guest Hosts After Chanel West Coast's Exit
- Russia claims to repel new attacks by Ukraine, but Kyiv urges silence on long-awaited counteroffensive
- Cincinnati Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow owns a $3 million Batmobile Tumbler
- Teen Mom's Jenelle Evans Says Relationship With Jace Is Closer Than Ever After Custody Battle
- JoJo Siwa's Ex Katie Mills Reacts to Clout Chasing and Love Bombing Accusations
- Jennifer Aniston Teases Twists and Turns in The Morning Show Season 3
- Could your smelly farts help science?
- Sweden close to becoming first smoke free country in Europe as daily cigarette use dwindles
Ranking
- Spooky or not? Some Choa Chu Kang residents say community garden resembles cemetery
- Succession Just Made That Ludicrously Capacious Burberry Bag Go Viral
- As China raids U.S. businesses and arrests workers, the corporate landscape is getting very risky
- Nick Jonas' Hilariously Relatable Dad Moment Proves He's Only Human
- Behind on your annual reading goal? Books under 200 pages to read before 2024 ends
- What would a Trump or DeSantis 2024 U.S. election win mean for Ukraine as Russia's war grinds on?
- Royal Family Mourns Unexpected Death of Comedian Paul O'Grady
- What would a Trump or DeSantis 2024 U.S. election win mean for Ukraine as Russia's war grinds on?
Recommendation
Man can't find second winning lottery ticket, sues over $394 million jackpot, lawsuit says
Why Justine Bateman Doesn't Give a S--t About Criticism Over Her Decision to Age Naturally
13 family members die after reportedly eating toxic porridge in Namibia
Veteran journalist shot dead while leaving his home in Mexico
Appeals court scraps Nasdaq boardroom diversity rules in latest DEI setback
Nordstrom's Unreal Spring Sale Is Here With Up to 70% Off Deals on Free People, Vince Camuto, Dior & More
Transcript: Brad Smith, Microsoft president and vice chair, on Face the Nation, May 28, 2023
Why Women Everywhere Love Dani Marie's Sustainable, Plus-Sized Fashion