Current:Home > ScamsBoth sides argue for resolution of verdict dispute in New Hampshire youth center abuse case -Elite Financial Minds
Both sides argue for resolution of verdict dispute in New Hampshire youth center abuse case
View
Date:2025-04-18 08:15:04
CONCORD, N.H. (AP) — The $38 million verdict in a landmark lawsuit over abuse at New Hampshire’s youth detention center remains disputed nearly four months later, with both sides submitting final requests to the judge this week.
“The time is nigh to have the issues fully briefed and decided,” Judge Andrew Schulman wrote in an order early this month giving parties until Wednesday to submit their motions and supporting documents.
At issue is the $18 million in compensatory damages and $20 million in enhanced damages a jury awarded to David Meehan in May after a monthlong trial. His allegations of horrific sexual and physical abuse at the Youth Development Center in 1990s led to a broad criminal investigation resulting in multiple arrests, and his lawsuit seeking to hold the state accountable was the first of more than 1,100 to go to trial.
The dispute involves part of the verdict form in which jurors found the state liable for only “incident” of abuse at the Manchester facility, now called the Sununu Youth Services Center. The jury wasn’t told that state law caps claims against the state at $475,000 per “incident,” and some jurors later said they wrote “one” on the verdict form to reflect a single case of post-traumatic stress disorder resulting from more than 100 episodes of physical, sexual and emotional abuse.
In an earlier order, Schulman said imposing the cap, as the state has requested, would be an “unconscionable miscarriage of justice.” But he suggested in his Aug. 1 order that the only other option would be ordering a new trial, given that the state declined to allow him to adjust the number of incidents.
Meehan’s lawyers, however, have asked Schulman to set aside just the portion of the verdict in which jurors wrote one incident, allowing the $38 million to stand, or to order a new trial focused only on determining the number of incidents.
“The court should not be so quick to throw the baby out with the bath water based on a singular and isolated jury error,” they wrote.
“Forcing a man — who the jury has concluded was severely harmed due to the state’s wanton, malicious, or oppressive conduct — to choose between reliving his nightmare, again, in a new and very public trial, or accepting 1/80th of the jury’s intended award, is a grave injustice that cannot be tolerated in a court of law,” wrote attorneys Rus Rilee and David Vicinanzo.
Attorneys for the state, however, filed a lengthy explanation of why imposing the cap is the only correct way to proceed. They said jurors could have found that the state’s negligence caused “a single, harmful environment” in which Meehan was harmed, or they may have believed his testimony only about a single episodic incident.
In making the latter argument, they referred to an expert’s testimony “that the mere fact that plaintiff may sincerely believe he was serially raped does not mean that he actually was.”
Meehan, 42, went to police in 2017 to report the abuse and sued the state three years later. Since then, 11 former state workers have been arrested, although one has since died and charges against another were dropped after the man, now in his early 80s, was found incompetent to stand trial.
The first criminal case goes to trial Monday. Victor Malavet, who has pleaded not guilty to 12 counts of aggravated felonious sexual assault, is accused of assaulting a teenage girl at a pretrial facility in Concord in 2001.
veryGood! (1375)
Related
- Meet the volunteers risking their lives to deliver Christmas gifts to children in Haiti
- Reese Witherspoon Mourns Death of Her Dog Hank
- Ryan Reynolds Hilariously Confronts Blake Lively's Costar Brandon Sklenar Over Suggestive Photo
- See damage left by Debby: Photos show flooded streets, downed trees after hurricane washes ashore
- EU countries double down on a halt to Syrian asylum claims but will not yet send people back
- Wall Street hammered amid plunging global markets | The Excerpt
- After dark days on stock markets, see where economy stands now
- Trump's bitcoin stockpile plan stirs debate in cryptoverse
- McKinsey to pay $650 million after advising opioid maker on how to 'turbocharge' sales
- Exclusive: Oklahoma death row inmate Emmanuel Littlejohn wants forgiveness, mercy
Ranking
- Bodycam footage shows high
- Republican activist becomes first person to be convicted in Arizona’s fake elector case
- Software upgrades for Hyundai, Kia help cut theft rates, new HLDI research finds
- New England’s largest energy storage facility to be built on former mill site in Maine
- McKinsey to pay $650 million after advising opioid maker on how to 'turbocharge' sales
- Texas schools got billions in federal pandemic relief, but it is coming to an end as classes begin
- Florida man charged after lassoing 9-foot alligator: 'I was just trying to help'
- Devin Booker performance against Brazil latest example of Team USA's offensive depth
Recommendation
Justice Department, Louisville reach deal after probe prompted by Breonna Taylor killing
Caeleb Dressel on his Olympics, USA swimming's future and wanting to touch grass
The Daily Money: Recovering from Wall Street's manic Monday
Taylor Swift leads VMA nominations (again) but there are 29 first-timers too: See the list
Paula Abdul settles lawsuit with former 'So You Think You Can Dance' co
Spain vs. Brazil highlights: Brazil holds off comeback, will play for Olympic gold
Duane Thomas, who helped Dallas Cowboys win Super Bowl VI, dies at 77
I was an RA for 3 Years; Here are the Not-So-Obvious Dorm Essentials You Should Pack for College in 2024